Homemade Pizza Dough Experiment

What flour is best when making pizza dough? This is a question I often get asked so I decided do an experiment and make three pizzas using three different types and combinations of flour: white, whole wheat, and spelt. Before we get to the results, I’ve detail the three types of flour used and provide their nutritional information below.

1. White flour  is highly processed. The bran and the germ, which contain most of the nutrients, are removed during processing. I use Wegmans All Purpose Enriched, Unbleached, Unbromated Flour. While enriched white flour is restored with some nutrients (fiber, protein, and vitamin B), it is not as healthy as wheat flour. I don’t recommend consuming anything that is bleached and since some argue that potassium bromate is carcinogenic to humans, I  recommend purchasing unbromated flour. In short, white flour is the least expensive flour, but also the least healthy.

2. Whole wheat flour includes the entire grain. You will notice that the red whole grain leads to more texture and a brownish color. For this experiment I used King Arthur Unbleached Whole Wheat Organic Flour. Most people looking to make a healthier pizza tend to use a combination of wheat and white flour. From my experience, the 100% whole-wheat store bought dough and whole wheat pizzas from local pizzerias taste dry and bland.

3. Spelt flour is a species of wheat with yellow-brown color and higher fiber content than white flour. Spelt four is marketed as  having a “nutty” flavor. Some individuals that employ alternative medicine include spelt in their diet for treating bowel disease and allergies. However, a study from the American Institute of Baking and Colorado State University suggests that the superior nutritional claims about spelt wheat may be unfounded. I use Arrowhead Mills Organic Spelt Flower.

Nutritional Information

Amount Per Serving
White Wheat Spelt
Calories 110 110 130
Total Fat 0g .5g 1g
Carbohydrate 23g 23g 25g
Dietary Fiber 0g 4g 4g
Protein 3g 4g 4g

Pizza Dough Experiement Results
I evaluated the dough at 5 different stages: mixing, proofing, after rolling, after pre-baking and the final product. Each dough was pre-baked for 4 minutes, topped, and then baked for an additional 7 minutes at 500 degrees on a pizza stone.

Pizza 1: White 50%, Wheat 50%

1. Mixing: added 1.5 tablespoons of water
2. Proofing: very similar to the wheat/spelt
3. Rolled out: not as nicely as the wheat/spelt , but not as much as white/spelt
4. After pre-bake: fluffier
5. End product:  edges browned the fastest, it was softer and not as firm
Rating: 3 slices (okay)

Pizza 2: White 50%, Spelt 50%

1. Mixing: a little sticky
2. Proofing:  got soft and fluffy quickly
3. Rolled out: didn’t keep its shape as easily and took some elbow grease to roll
4. After pre-bake:  a little soft with some air bubbles
5. End product:  light, crispy, and firm
Rating : 4 slices (delicious)

Pizza 3: Wheat 50%, Spelt 50%

1. Mixing: too dry, I need to add 1 tablespoon water
2. Proofing: didn’t rise as much as the other two
3. Rolled out: easy, like cookie dough
4. After pre-bake: underside more crispy
5. End product:  the edge of this pizza is browner, but not because of heat. This pizza was not as crunchy, but it was still firm. This was the most bland crust of the three.  In fact, the pizza was so dry that it gave my husband the hiccups.
Rating: 2 slices (tasted like cardboard)

Making pizza dough from scratch is easier than most think, but knowing what combination of flour to use can be tricky. This experiment taught me a few things. First, as much I’d like a healthy crust, you need to use white flour. Second, whole-wheat flour is easier to work with, but it doesn’t have the texture or flavor of spelt flour. Finally, my original 50% white, 50% spelt combination is the combination I enjoy most, but I imagine that it’s a personal choice so I look forward to hearing from you about the combination of flour you use to make thin crust pizza.

Arrowhead Mills Spelt Flour, Whole Grain, 2 Pound Bag

King Arthur Flour, Og, White Whl Wheat


2 responses to “Homemade Pizza Dough Experiment

  1. Please share your recipe for pizza dough if you haven’t yet. If you have, please point me to it. 🙂
    Nice post!

  2. Yes, I too would love the full recipe… I know I saw it once, but haven’t been able to find it again. Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s